The Chambliss/Obama Victory

Charles Krauthammer posited an interesting theory during the "FOX All-Stars" segment of Special Report today. In his mind the real winner of last night's runoff election contest in Georgia was President-Elect Obama, the reason being that Jim Martin's deficit was three points in the general election when the PE was on top of the ballot but was fifteen points when he was not. This will allow the President-Elect to make the claim to Democrats in Congress, in Krauthammer's estimation, that his political star is carrying them and that they need to get behind him and insure his administration's success to insure their own.

It is an interesting idea, but not especially persuasive. For one, the next President will be able to make that argument anyway as any President eligible for re-election would. The success of the party who holds the White House is determined by how the public perceives its individual occupant. If they view him positively, it helps the party; if they view him negatively, it is a drag, to one degree or another.

Also, run-off elections are notorious for their low turnout because they come after a long campaign after which everyone is usually campaign-weary and not especially keen on voting again. As a result the vote usually goes to the default choice, i.e. to the incumbent or member of the predominant party in the voting area. This is exactly what happened in Georgia, a reliably Republican state where the Republican incumbent won convincingly.

If the result from yesterday tells us anything beyond that it is that President-Elect Obama's convincing victory was almost entirely predicated upon the extreme unpopularity of the outgoing Republican incumbent. For practical purposes now the PE is the President, and so the fuel for his and the Democrats' success is gone, at least for their recent success. Sen. Chambliss was able to run in the last month against a Democratic President and Congress, plausibly billing himself as a needed check against this liberal juggernaut. That's the recipe for success in a state reliably Republican.